Get your anxieties in order.
Updated: 1 day ago
In recent months western governments have encouraged us, individually and collectively “to make preparations”. They have suggested that citizens “get their houses in order” and infer the likelihood of something catastrophic occurring, in the very near future. Some administrations have even suggested that “War”
is imminent, if not highly likely to occur within the next three years.
The Guardian newspaper writes “Every Briton should stockpile water and food supplies, government advises” 22nd October 2026.”
This headline might not simply be a call to action, but suggest the likelihood for upheaval, commensurate to that developed during the recent Covid 19 event, for which we were supposedly unprepared. Instead it offers a new and perhaps more frightening discourse for social and cultural disturbance, the likes of which we have not experienced for several generations?! Consequently this headline has become an obvious topic of conversation among families, communities and the chattering classes. One spurred on by curiously recent ruptures in tech, air travel and banking.
On one level the instruction to store food and water might appear entirely practical. However, it also touches something far more primitive: a childlike vulnerability and dependence upon the world around us.
This world ordinarily provides a reassuring framework within which we can comfortably conduct our lives and - to a degree - safely and without fear for our survival. We turn on a tap, buy food, switch on the lights and assume that these things will continue to be available to us, with or without our demands upon them.
So what happens psychoanalytically, when that assumption is disturbed?
The Individual
From a Kleinian perspective the need to prepare - in response to an as yet unexperienced threat - can evoke quite primitive anxieties, related to vulnerability, persecution and the threat of annihilation. In short our earliest anxieties about survival can be reawakened.
Indeed the fact that governments and institutions in whom we (perhaps mistakenly at times) place our trust and security are suggesting a threat (which is not concretely divulged), presents us with an internal conflict and further anxiety. The sort of anxiety a young child may experience when their parents become suddenly hysterical with fear (screaming and shouting) and yet protective (hugging tightly) toward that same event.
To compound this. Our anxieties are strangely compelling and often compliant, in response to such an instruction. Freud’s concept of the death drive with further interrogation by Klein and Lacan informs us that perhaps perversely we are attracted to the notion of catastrophe. We are not necessarily seeking the point of catastrophe itself, but the associated feelings to it. It frightened us. And being frightened - in most people - forms a compulsion to understand something that was once intolerable.
The headline becomes an object of fascination. We read about the threat, discuss it, imagine its consequences and return to it again.
Perhaps the frightening possibility offers a peculiar kind of psychological satisfaction: it gives shape to otherwise diffuse anxieties about the future, our vulnerability and the fragility of the world we inhabit.
The group.
At a group level powerful forces are activated. Bion suggested that group dynamics evoke and propagate anxieties in particular ways. In a herd-like manner, the signal of one becomes the signal of many. We discuss the headlines and watch our reactions to it. At the extremes, those in the group that suffer an acute fear response invite those less fearful to ask, “what do they know or assume, that I don’t?”
Bion described how groups can become organised around unconscious assumptions, including the expectation of danger and the need to find protection from it.
When uncertainty becomes collective, people may begin responding less to the actual likelihood of an event and more to the emotional atmosphere surrounding it.
Hannah Arendts seminal work takes this even further by suggesting that over time, without a clear object for our anxieties (free-floating) and in response to the instruction of a powerful authority, the group can become a psychological mass, acting collectively - irrationally and primitively. If the society in question is atomised (that is to say comprising mainly of lonely individuals), saturated with media of testimonial or inferentially obtained knowledge, this mass can gain potency becoming aggravated, embedded and eventually totalitarian in its overall nature. This fearful society gradually becomes more susceptible to ideological currents and relentless propaganda. For those who speak out, scapegoating arises, cancellation and ostracisation.
One might predict that modern Western culture is rather vulnerable in this regard however, could it be argued that since 2020 the public has become less affected by government warnings and therefore less inclined to react with fear and anxiety in response?
Disclaimer: The material provided in this post is for informational purposes only and not intended to diagnose, treat, or prevent any illness in readers. The information should not replace personalised care from your provider or formal supervision if you’re a practitioner or student.